Maximizing shareholder value is typically one of the primary objectives of large corporations, as this will result in the company's overall success - if this is the case, there are a few methods that they can use. The best method for companies to boost shareholder value is to increase profits, which will boost the price of their shares, but then returning cash to shareholders through dividend payments and share repurchases is the next best thing.
Although dividend payments used to be one of the more popular methods of returning capital to shareholders, share buybacks have been gaining in their use, and they have plenty of benefits and cautions to take into consideration before you take part, so we’ll focus on them here.
What are share buybacks?
The reacquisition of a company's own shares is known as a share repurchase, or share buyback. This is an alternative, and adaptable method of repaying capital to shareholders, and it may boost share prices.
Investors can choose whether or not they want to participate in a buyback and sell their shares back to the company. Often they will be offered an above-market rate to entice them to do so.
Why are companies using share buybacks?
There's a few reasons why this method has gained popularity.
First up, since a share buyback reduces the number of outstanding shares, it raises the company's earnings per share (EPS) and decreases the P/E ratio. The remaining shares might see a price increase as a result, because investors might see them as a more attractive asset.
When you remember that each share of common shares represents ownership interest in the issuing company, as well as the right to vote on the company's financial and operational decisions, reducing the number of shareholders can make sense if the company wishes to gain back some control and consolidate ownership.
Also, companies issue shares in the first place to raise equity capital in order to finance expansion, but if there are no prospective development opportunities, holding on to all that unused equity funding is bad for business.
Pros and opportunities for investors
- Share buybacks may provide a short-term gain for investors in the form of a rise in share prices. As a result of the repurchase, there are now fewer shares available on the open market, and the value of their investment may rise.
- As a result of fewer shares being outstanding, the corporation may be in a position to boost dividend payments after a repurchase.
- Increased earnings per share, which is a key metric used by investors to monitor the performance of publicly traded firms after they report financial results, can be boosted on the back of lower trading volume. The share price may then increase if they outperform market expectations.
- Investors often interpret share repurchases as an indication that a firm thinks its share price should be higher and that its actual worth is undervalued by the market, and the stock market's rising trend often begins with this expectation.
Cons and cautions for investors
- The goal is for companies to purchase back their shares while they’re cheap, but in reality, this sometimes doesn’t happen. After all, nobody knows what the stock market will do, and in many cases, companies buy back their shares at prices that turn out to be too expensive, making the buyback a waste of money.
- When a company invests heavily in share repurchases, the dividend is sometimes reduced as a consequence. The company's ability to pay out dividends every quarter may have decreased after it spent money buying back those shares. This may be a financial blow for shareholders who rely on dividend payments.
- It can be seen as a waste of money for a corporation to spend millions on repurchasing its own shares, and astute shareholders will naturally wonder why. Every dollar spent on share buybacks is a dollar that isn't being invested in expanding the firm in some other way, for example by adding additional workers, increasing advertising, purchasing a rival, creating innovative products, etc.
- Large shareholders, such as the company's management if they have stock options, tend to profit the most from stock buybacks. If the repurchase causes a temporary increase in the share price, that increase might be enough to allow management to exercise their options. In this way, the executives may swiftly resell their shares and pocket the gains. Therefore, upper management benefits while other areas of the business such as R&D, marketing, and recruitment among others, can suffer.
Will you always profit from share buybacks? It all depends on the signal sent to the market participants
Buyback announcements are seen as a signal by the market since they provide insight into the future of a business and its share price.
Management's apparent belief that the share price is cheap is one well-known and encouraging indication in a repurchase. When executives buy more shares for themselves, it gives the impression that they have intimate knowledge about the company's chances for development and profit.
Another assumption investors may make is that management isn't worried about finding funds to pay for things like interest and capital outlays in the future, which is another good indicator.
A repurchase, however, could send a third and negative signal to investors: that the management team believes there are few promising investment prospects ahead.
While this may make some managers hesitant to initiate buyback programs, the generally favorable response of the stock market to such announcements suggests that this signal is not a concern in most circumstances.
Dividend vs Share buybacks: What’s best for investors?
Both share buybacks and dividend payments are methods by which corporations distribute cash to shareholders. In contrast to a dividend, which returns cash to all shareholders, a share buyback returns cash only to those who elect to participate.
Both dividends and share repurchases can increase the total return on your shares, but there is debate over which is superior for investors and companies over the long term.
Profits are distributed as dividends to shareholders, who receive an immediate return (and tax liability). A share buyback reduces the number of outstanding shares, which should result in a long-term increase in the share price.
So should you participate in a buyback? This will depend on the conditions set for the repurchase, your own financial state, and your assessment of the company's prospects for the future. The offer price, the repurchase's funding method, and any potential tax obligations for you are a few things to think about when deciding whether or not to take part in a share buyback.
The choice ultimately rests with each individual shareholder.
The information provided does not constitute investment research. The material has not been prepared in accordance with the legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is to be considered to be a marketing communication.
All information has been prepared by ActivTrades (“AT”). The information does not contain a record of AT’s prices, or an offer of or solicitation for a transaction in any financial instrument. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information.
Any material provided does not have regard to the specific investment objective and financial situation of any person who may receive it. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. AT provides an execution-only service. Consequently, any person acting on the information provided does so at their own risk.